65% of this site rates MitB 5 Stars!?

FREAKS!?

5 matches;

A painful diva's match
A terrible Show v Henry match
The SmackDown! MitB was fairly good
The RAW! MitB had maybe 3 high moments and that was it
CM Punk v Cena was great

So you've two decent matches, two TERRIBLE matches and one great match and you give it 5 stars!? Yeah the ending was epic but that doesn't make up for a pretty boring and lacklusture PPV.

I seriously worry about the mindset of some of this sites posters.

....I enjoyed the entire PPV...So what?

I guarantee most of those people didn't watch it, and gave it 5 Stars because of the Punk win.

Meh, I gave it a four. Two Terrible matches and 4 good. :L

MichaelYourBestestFriend wrote:

Meh, I gave it a four. Two Terrible matches and 4 good. :L

I also gave it a 4, although I'm now thinking I should have given it a 3.

You forgot about Orton/Christian.

And they obviously are as guilty as John Cena and kissing Vince McMahon's ass. Now that Vince is out, they'll rate it 5-star for SummerSlam to get a head start on Triple H.

I rated it a 2-star.

"The Bobcat" Mikel wrote:

You forgot about Orton/Christian.

And they obviously are as guilty as John Cena and kissing Vince McMahon's ass. Now that Vince is out, they'll rate it 5-star for SummerSlam to get a head start on Triple H.

I rated it a 2-star.

What are you going on about?

"The Bobcat" Mikel wrote:

You forgot about Orton/Christian.

And they obviously are as guilty as John Cena and kissing Vince McMahon's ass. Now that Vince is out, they'll rate it 5-star for SummerSlam to get a head start on Triple H.

I rated it a 2-star.

This makes no sense.

Money in the Bank.

I gave it a four.
The only matches that appealed to me where the SD MitB and Punk winning match.
I shoulda gave it 3 stars now though ...

"The Bobcat" Mikel wrote:

Money in the Bank.

Words flow not well mouth from?

"The Bobcat" Mikel wrote:

You forgot about Orton/Christian.

And they obviously are as guilty as John Cena and kissing Vince McMahon's ass. Now that Vince is out, they'll rate it 5-star for SummerSlam to get a head start on Triple H.

I rated it a 2-star.

1) Orton vs Christian was a poor excuse for a match.

2) That don't make much sence.

3) Haven't you left yet?

SP... Didn't I explain to you? I left RPing and Booking. Then I got people asking me to come back so I did.

I gave it 2 although I was considering a three.

I just find it amusing when people do this yet shit on destination x.

Joey if you enjoyed it by all means but I find it hard to comprehend it as a 5 star ppv when I wouldn't class any match as 5 star. ie. the star system is flawed

My original 4 star review was given on a WWE scale, because it's their best in a while. After having a rethink, I would give it a 2 or a 3. And Adam, Destination X was better. Despite MITB's main event.

There were six matches, not five, you're forgetting the WHC.

All were good except Show/Henry and the divas, since they weren't anything to remember. The fact is, it is a PPV altogether that will be rememered, and rather than dissecting each match, that's what you look to do with a PPV.

Jarrett wrote:

There were six matches, not five, you're forgetting the WHC.

All were good except Show/Henry and the divas, since they weren't anything to remember. The fact is, it is a PPV altogether that will be rememered, and rather than dissecting each match, that's what you look to do with a PPV.

....Said the Kane fan.

Lil Jimmy wrote:

Jarrett wrote:

There were six matches, not five, you're forgetting the WHC.

All were good except Show/Henry and the divas, since they weren't anything to remember. The fact is, it is a PPV altogether that will be rememered, and rather than dissecting each match, that's what you look to do with a PPV.

....Said the Kane fan.

And what exactly does that have to do with MITB?

The RAW mitb or Orton/Christian weren't anything to shout about. Well that's stupid imo, Victory Road will always be remembered for Hardys drug induced performance does that make it 5 star? PPVs should be based on match quality and stories. Destination X should never be forgotten in terms of nostalga and pure match quality does that mean it'd be given 5 stars? I guarantee you if a similar poll went up here it'd get less than 3 by the majority of users.

I just strongly disagree with MITB being 5 stars or any PPV being 5 stars in quite a long time.

Everyone has a different opinion on these things.

God wrote:

The RAW mitb or Orton/Christian weren't anything to shout about. Well that's stupid imo, Victory Road will always be remembered for Hardys drug induced performance does that make it 5 star? PPVs should be based on match quality and stories. Destination X should never be forgotten in terms of nostalga and pure match quality does that mean it'd be given 5 stars? I guarantee you if a similar poll went up here it'd get less than 3 by the majority of users.

I just strongly disagree with MITB being 5 stars or any PPV being 5 stars in quite a long time.

The difference between remembering MITB because of Punk rather than remembering VR because of Hardy is simply because one is a positive thing and one is not.

I gave MITB 5 stars and liked Destination X a lot

Jarrett wrote:

God wrote:

The RAW mitb or Orton/Christian weren't anything to shout about. Well that's stupid imo, Victory Road will always be remembered for Hardys drug induced performance does that make it 5 star? PPVs should be based on match quality and stories. Destination X should never be forgotten in terms of nostalga and pure match quality does that mean it'd be given 5 stars? I guarantee you if a similar poll went up here it'd get less than 3 by the majority of users.

I just strongly disagree with MITB being 5 stars or any PPV being 5 stars in quite a long time.

The difference between remembering MITB because of Punk rather than remembering VR because of Hardy is simply because one is a positive thing and one is not.

Jarrett how do you have 16 PPV points, if you joined on Sunday.

Because this is his 3rd account, Mop. He added the points he got from the last PPV(s)

Richie wrote:

Because this is his 3rd account, Mop. He added the points he got from the last PPV(s)

Ah ok, well I though i was in the lead... This is dissapointing.